Is Knife-Making Profitable?

We know that everybody wants to make quick money nowadays, but as with anything, nothing great comes easy. In the last couple of years, knife-making got a lot of interest, especially after starting the popular TV show, Forged in Fire.

When you search for custom-made knives, you can expect to find some knives selling anywhere from 100 to 10,000 dollars. That can make you wonder, can you make a lot of money by making knives?

Knife-making can be extremely profitable if you put enough time and energy into it. When it comes to the business aspect of knife-making, the most important factors are having a passion and knowing the market. For some people, knife-making is a full-time business earning anywhere between 30,000$-200,000$ a year, while others struggle to sell even one knife.

Of course, there is much more to it when building a profitable knife-making business. The rest of the article will discuss how you can take your business to the next level and answer some frequently asked questions.

How to Develop a Successful Knife-Making Business?

Any great business takes time to develop. The same thing applies to knife-making. You can’t just expect to make big money right away. Ask any knife-maker, and they will tell you the same thing.

A few important characteristics that distinguish a successful professional knife-maker are:

  • Passion for the craft
  • Have a decent prior experience in making knives
  • Constant learning and developing knowledge about knifes
  • Knowing the market

Passion is self-explanatory; you have to love what you do. Without it, you will burn out very quickly. You will not get that far if you start knife-making ONLY to make money. Remember why you started making knives in the first place. If you are not passionate about it, your business will eventually fail. Of course, there will be some days when you don’t feel like doing it, but that’s acceptable; everyone has it. The important thing is that you keep going.

Before starting a knife-making business, you should already have some decent experience. It takes some time and practice to become very good at it. Except that, so far, you should already know what makes a great knife. When it comes to knives, many factors are crucial during their making process, including the choice of material, design, balance, proper heat treatment, etc.

When we first started making blades, it was purely for enjoyment and personal use. Sometimes we would make a knife as a gift for somebody. We did it only for fun. One day, a friend asked us to make a hunting knife for him. He only needed to cover the cost of the material.

After a few days, we started getting inquiries from a local hunting community that our friend recommended to us. They asked us if we would like to make some money and produce ten more similar knives.

That was our first business deal. Being paid for something you love doing is an incredible feeling. After that, we just kept learning about various knives and other blades. Not long after that, we were getting offers from local barbershops to produce straight razors for them.

At that time, each of us earned about 300 dollars a week. It was only a part-time job, and it was a nice side income.

Every successful knife-maker started making knives as a hobby and eventually turned them into a business. It is one thing to make a knife for a friend, but selling a knife to a customer is completely another thing. In case of that knife breaks, a friend will probably forgive you while a customer will not. A customer paid for it, so they expect a good quality product in return.

Knowing the market is essential to developing a successful knife-making business. Let’s say that, for some reason, you like making fishing knives, but you only have one prospect every few months interested in buying them. On the other hand, you have 15 prospects interested in buying kitchen-knifes a month. Knowing what option is more beneficial for your business?

Although it seems obvious, a lot of people make this mistake. Instead of focusing on kitchen knives, which may be less enjoyable to make or for whatever reason it may be, they focus on fishing knives.

Maybe they like hunting knives more, but the problem is that the market does not have a high demand for them. The law of supply and demand is crucial to every business, including knife-making.

Another huge mistake many knife-makers make is to focus only on highly expensive knives and hope someone will buy them. That can be an even bigger issue if you only sell in your local area. If people in your area simply can’t afford or don’t need these types of knives, don’t produce them. Listen to the market, and you will make a profit.

Just by looking at the premium kitchen knife brand Dalstrong Amazon store, you can see how they built their customer base from all over the world. They made sure their knives are all high-quality forged knives with lots of attention to detail. They’ve created a whole series of knives that are detailed specifically to sell in different parts of the world.

We can see that not only there are potential customers who appreciate quality, but also aesthetics and other things.

Are Custom Knives Worth the Money?

It is important to bear in mind that knives are not commodities. If a regular knife costs 50$ and a custom knife costs 500$, it does not mean that it is ten times better than the regular one. It might only be 10-20% better, depending on the choice of steel.

When a custom knife is being made, a knife maker is not much concerned with the cost of the material because a person who can afford it won’t mind spending 100$ more. So what is it about custom knives that make them expensive?

When you buy a custom knife, you actually buy the art of a highly skilled knife-maker. You simply don’t admire factory-made products as you do handmade products. A custom knife is suited for you and your needs. Another characteristic that separates factory and custom knives is attention to detail.

No machine in this world can replace the experienced and skillful knife-maker when it comes to refinement. If you compare the two types of knives, they may be the same at first, but if you look closely, you will notice that a custom knife is much more made in detail.

That being said, for someone who wants a normal knife for standard use, paying 1000$ for a custom knife is not worth it.

Contrarily, if you are a knife enthusiast, professional knife user, or knife collector, then paying two thousand dollars for a custom knife will probably be worth it.

If you are interested in buying a custom knife, you should know that you can find them at different price ranges.

  • The lower end is somewhere between 50-500$
  • The middle range is between 500-2000$
  • Higher-end is anywhere above 2000$

Are Handmade Knives Better Than Factory-Made Ones?

Handmade knives are mostly better than factory-made ones. The choice of a knife is based on important factors, such as:

  • Sharpness
  • Durability
  • Material
  • Design
  • Price

Sharpness is the obvious one. If a knife cannot cut, it is not a knife. Most factory-made knives are very sharp in the beginning, but the question is, how much do they last? Since they are not forged, they are more flexible, and therefore, edges last shorter than handmade ones.

Compared to handmade knives, sharpening is way harder to perform on factory-made ones, mainly because of its flexibility. Handmade knives are forged, which means that they are hard and strong. Also, the edges of a handmade knife are much sharper and long-lasting.

Durability is another important factor to consider when buying a knife. Typically, a handmade knife is much more durable, knowing the fact that it is forged. You can use forged knives for many years without losing their sharpness. Handmade knives are much less flexible, which makes them easier to sharpen.

Of course, the material used to make a knife is of great importance. Every handmade knife is made from stainless steel, Damascus steel, or high-carbon steel. All of these are high-quality materials for knife-making. Factory-made knives do not always use these types of steel or sometimes even steel at all.

Although not the most important factor, the design of a knife is one more factor to consider. Factory-made knives are mostly based on quantity over quality. Workers in the factory have a daily production target that they have to achieve and therefore can’t concentrate on every blade efficiently. Handmade knives are all about quality and attention to detail, so most of the time, they are much nicer in design.

As with any product, price is a major determinant when buying a knife. If you are on a tight budget, then factory-made knives are your option as they are much cheaper. On the other hand, handmade knives would be a better choice if you are a great enthusiast or professional knife user. Yes, they are more expensive but be sure they are worth it.

PROS of handmade knives

  • Much sharper
  • Long-lasting
  • High-quality material
  • Nice design
  • Made with great detail

CONS of handmade knives

  • Expensive

PROS of factory-made knives

  • Readily available
  • Cheap

CONS of factory-made knives

  • Low durability
  • Basic design
  • No attention to detail

This Post Has One Comment

  1. Soban

    Hello, I am a knife maker and we make all knifes, can I sell knifes

Leave a Reply